The Artist Who Filled a Storied Village Hotel With Her Own Tile Work Has Died at 99

Google Maps

The ceramic tile portraits that line the walls of one of Greenwich Village’s oldest hotels are staying put under its new owners, but the artist who made them has died. She was 99.

Rita Paul, whose family owned the Washington Square Hotel on the northwest corner of Washington Square Park for 52 years, died on Monday at her home in the Village. Her daughter, Judy Paul, told The New York Times that the cause was congestive heart failure.

Paul took on the title of the hotel’s artistic director and used an in-house kiln to recreate her favorite paintings in glazed ceramic tile. Her version of John Singer Sargent’s “Madame X” was the lobby’s centerpiece, and her take on Tamara de Lempicka’s nude “La Belle Rafaëla” stretched across the bar. Throughout the rest of the building were tile versions of Gustav Klimt works and Vogue covers, tile portraits of 1930s and ’40s movie stars like Marlene Dietrich, Joan Crawford and Ann Sheridan, and her own oil paintings of New York City scenes. She also put in marble floors styled after parts of the Louvre, along with a metal gate she found at an antique store in Paris.

She was born Rita Ursel Puchalski in Berlin on April 1, 1927. Her family was Jewish and moved to Paris after the Nazis took power in 1933. Her father soon re-established himself in New York, while her mother stayed in Paris with the two children until 1940, when she found a way out of Europe with a single suitcase. Once in New York, the family shortened its name to Puchall and went from construction into the hotel business. Rita studied art at Hunter College and graduated in 1947. She married Daniel Paul in 1949. She steered clear of Manhattan galleries because she wanted a less cutthroat outlet for her work, and she turned down commissions so she could focus on the hotel.

The Pauls paid $900,000 in 1973 for what was then the Hotel Earle: two connected nine-story buildings and a three-story annex, with space for 165 rooms. By then the place had sunk into squalor, and most of its residents were on welfare. In a 2022 interview with the Times, Paul said it had become a dump for small-time criminals. The family moved in seven years after buying it, and in 1986 they dropped the Earle name, which had become linked with the building’s decline.

The hotel opened in 1902 and has a long cultural résumé. In 1961, Bob Dylan moved in with folk singer Ramblin’ Jack Elliott, shortly after Dylan arrived from Minneapolis. Joan Baez also stayed there with Dylan, a period she later wrote about in her song “Diamonds and Rust.” Novelist Patricia Highsmith used the hotel for trysts, and it inspired her short story “Notes From a Respectable Cockroach.” The Coen brothers’ 1991 film “Barton Fink” is set at a hotel called the Earle, and the B-52s stayed there in the 1970s while they were in town to play CBGB. Under the Pauls, Bo Diddley, a friend of Rita’s who had a regular room, played in the lobby for the hotel’s centennial. Around the same time, a then-unknown waitress named Norah Jones asked to fill in as a singer at the hotel’s jazz brunch.

In 2025, the family sold the hotel and its adjoining restaurant, North Square, for $29 million to a group led by hotelier Henry Kallan that includes the owners of the Chelsea Hotel. Judy Paul told the Times that the family cleared $23 million after paying off its mortgage. She said the deal requires some of the hotel’s old character to be preserved, and that the new owners have committed to keeping her mother’s tile portraits on the walls. She added that her mother’s art had always been the symbol of the hotel’s independence.

“You’ll never be able to duplicate that anywhere,” she said.

Daniel Paul died in 2017. Judy is Rita Paul’s only immediate survivor.

.

Get us in your inbox!